A sandwich is a subjective experience. Some people like wholegrain, some people don’t like coriander (RIP your palate potential bro), some people like em soft, and some like a jagged crust that poses an immediate threat to your gum health. I like pretty simple sandwiches with big flavours, stimulating texture, and usually one flare that breaks standard convention. Here are some of the chicken sandwiches I like to eat in Melbourne.
This review will be split into two chicken sandwich categories: crispy schnitzel style and roast/poached chicken salad style.
Crispy
Carlito’s
"Cotolleta"

This sandwich tastes like it was made by someone’s cool, hot aunt who knows exactly where to get the best tinned fish and for some reason the salad she makes is always fresher and better tasting than when you try to recreate it.
Beautiful piece of schnitzel, quick pickled onion that isn't overpowering, herb salad, cucumbers, shallots and green goddess dressing for said cool aunt flare. Crunchy, fresh, punchy and filling – but not heavy, I have no more requirements out of a schnitty sandwich.
I sat in the back courtyard on a beautiful sunny day, Carlito (of sandwich fame) came out with a big smile, recognised me and broke the ice (even though it's been a decade since seeing each other) and hand delivered this beautiful sandwich wrapped in the same deli paper that would encase all the cured meats I’d eat as a kid. Good people make good food.
32 Stanley St, Collingwood VIC 3066
N. Tran
"Schnitzel Roll"

No one has formulated a better schnitzel sandwich than this. Crispy thin schnitty, tomato, cucumber, carrot, shredded lettuce, CANNED beetroot, pepper in one of those steel shakers that comes out as a dusting, very slightly translucent mayonnaise that I would recoil from in any other setting, and just the right amount of chilli on a sesame seed baguette. I’m not even a beetroot head but I once tried this sandwich without it and I wish it never happened, everything about this sandwich is perfect. Still cheap, still lightning fast and still tastes exactly the same as when I first tried it 15 years ago. That’s just bloody good business.
Multiple locations, but Smith Street is probably the pick
Juju’s Deli
"Chicken Schnitzel Sandwich"

I’ll be honest it’s been at least a year since I last ate this sandwich but it made such an impact that I had to include it. I rocked up on a sunny but chilly Sunday morning, brutally hungover and feeling more than a little peckish (as a result of my usual salve for a dusty Sunday). Wasn’t thrilled that the price began with a 2, but when this sandwich arrived it all made sense. House-made focaccia, three decent pieces of schnitty, cheese, spicy mayo, and (buzzword alert!) yuzu slaw. This thing was bigger than my head, dude. The crunch was perfect, it was the right amount of spicy, and the yuzu came through in the slaw in a way that didn’t leave me wondering why the fuck it was in there. It entered my system and king-hit my hangover before I’d even started the second half.
249 Coventry St, South Melbourne & 750 High St, Thornbury
Non crispy
Boire
"Smoked Chicken Roll"

This is the simplest sandwich on this list but I really like it because it knows exactly what it’s doing. Smoky charcoal chicken, bitter lettuce, pickled onions, green chili aioli, bread roll from Bread Club. All the ingredients are clearly well considered and culminate in a very adult sandwich for when you’re feeling tasteful and refined. The smoky flavour in the chicken is delicious, and doesn’t fall victim to the muddy, off-putting stank that so many foods regress into when you put the word "smoked" in front of them. This in itself is enough to set it apart from the hordes of pesto chicken sandwiches, but then the lovely bitter crunch of the leaves takes it home.
8 Errol St, North Melbourne VIC 3051
Juniper
"Roast Chicken Roll"

I drive at least 30 minutes to get this sandwich. This is a destination sandwich. This tastes like someone made it at home for someone they love. Roast chicken, garlic mayo, leafy greens, crispy chicken skin and salsa verde on a nice big roll. This one still sticks out for me in an area that has quickly become the sandwich mecca of Melbourne. Roast chicken that’s not too dry but also not goobly, crispy chicken skin speaks for itself, salsa verde gives it the necessary zing and a generous serving size. If I could make this myself I wouldn’t eat much else for lunch for the next 2 years, but I can’t, so this remains a lunchtime pilgrimage whenever I get a hankering for one.
269 Coventry St, South Melbourne VIC 3205
Morning Market
"Chicken Sandwich"

I’ve eaten this sandwich so much that I didn’t want to put it on the list. But that fact in itself shows that it deserves some flowers. A mix of poached chicken, green apple, celery, walnuts, mayonnaise and coarse grain mustard. Sat on the all important barrier of watercress and cos lettuce with a further reinforcement of butter to protect the very soft, very white bread from a soggy fate. The walnuts alone would’ve activated my “wow that’s a little bit different” response but green apple too dude? That’s a textural odyssey right there. I’m not sure if this is a tried and true recipe in the more French parts of the world, but wow, the last time I was this taken by a texture combo was when I first slapped a handful of Smith’s salt and vinnies in between two heavily buttered pieces of wonder white. Most of the time I’ll keep an eye out for their specials, in particular the chicken Caesar roll, but if they don’t have that on the menu this is the easiest, most consistent lunch option around Gertrude and Nicholson st that I can think of.
59 Gertrude St, Fitzroy VIC 3065
--
Honorable mentions:
Fried Guys katsu dipper sandwich, Moonee Ponds.
To’s Bakery BBQ Chicken Roll is also an all timer.






